Calculator to determine blended interest rate

Get Cash Out and Leave Your First Mortgage Alone

Casey Fleming
Lock in a low blended interest rate
Keep your low-interest rate first mortgage

During 2020 and 2021 millions of homeowners took out first mortgages at very low interest rates. I know, because I arranged them for a bunch of you. Now those same homeowners are sitting on a ton of equity—hundreds of thousands of dollars, if not a million dollars or more. The question I hear often is “How can I access that equity but still enjoy the benefit of my super-low-rate 30-year fixed?”

The obvious answer is a second mortgage or home equity line of credit. These products either carry a higher interest rate or a variable rate, however. So how would a homeowner go about determining if it’s better to get a cash-out first mortgage, or keep the first and get a second? Fortunately, math will help us figure this out.

A Deeper Dive: What are the advantages of a second mortgage?

A blended interest rate can be used to combine the rates of the two loans into a single, weighted average rate. This article will explain how blended interest rates work using the example of a first and second mortgage, and explore why they are important for homeowners who are managing multiple loans.

What is a Blended Interest Rate?

A blended interest rate is essentially an average interest rate that combines the interest rates of two or more loans. It is calculated by weighing the rate of each loan according to the loan’s balance or principal. For example, if you have a first mortgage with a larger balance and a second mortgage with a smaller balance, the interest rate of the first mortgage will have a greater influence on the overall blended rate.

This blended rate is important because it gives borrowers a more comprehensive view of what they will be paying in interest across multiple loans. Instead of dealing with multiple interest rates, the blended rate provides a simplified calculation for determining the total cost of borrowing.

Example: Blended Interest Rates with First and Second Mortgages

To understand how a blended interest rate works in practice, let’s look at an example using a first mortgage and a second mortgage.

Calculator to determine blended interest rate
Easy Math Using Excel

Scenario 1:

  • You currently have a first mortgage of $300,000 at an interest rate of 3.0%.
  • You decide to take out a second mortgage (often referred to as a home equity loan or line of credit) of $50,000 at an interest rate of 8.0%.

Now, let’s calculate the blended interest rate for these two loans. The total loan balance in this case is:

$300,000 + $50,000 = $350,000

Next, we calculate the weighted interest rate for each loan based on its proportion of the total balance.

For the first mortgage, the balance is $300,000, which is 85.7% of the total loan amount.

For the second mortgage, the balance is $50,000, which is 14.3% of the total loan amount .

Now, to calculate the blended interest rate:

Blended Interest Rate = (0.857×3.0%) + (0.143×8.0%) = 2.571% + 1.144% = 3.715%

So, the blended interest rate for these two loans is approximately 3.72%. Compare this to refinancing with a cash-out mortgage and it becomes abundantly clear in this scenario that a second mortgage is a good choice.

Scenario 2:

Calculator to determine blended interest rate
Larger second mortgages increase the blended rate
  • You currently have a first mortgage of $300,000 at an interest rate of 3.0%.
  • You decide to take out a second mortgage (often referred to as a home equity loan or line of credit) of $400,000 at an interest rate of 8.0%.

Now, let’s calculate the blended interest rate for these two loans. The total loan balance in this case is:

$300,000 + $400,000 = $700,000

Next, we calculate the weighted interest rate for each loan based on its proportion of the total balance.

For the first mortgage, the balance is $300,000, which is 42.9% of the total loan amount.

For the second mortgage, the balance is $400,000, which is 57.1% of the total loan amount .

Now, to calculate the blended interest rate:

Blended Interest Rate = (0.429 × 3.0%) + (0.571 × 8.0%) = 1.287% + 4.568% = 5.855%

So, the blended interest rate for these two loans is approximately 5.86%. Getting a second mortgage is still cheaper than refinancing with a cash-out first as measured by total interest rate, but other considerations might come into play.

Why Use a Blended Interest Rate?

Blended interest rates are particularly useful for homeowners who are trying to assess the overall cost of their mortgages when they have more than one. Here are a couple of reasons why a blended rate is important:

Budgeting and Financial Planning

For financial planning, understanding the blended interest rate gives borrowers a more accurate sense of their long-term interest costs.

Evaluating Loan Strategies

I have always advised clients that their long-term plan to manage debt is more important than getting the lowest interest rate. Homeowners who are considering paying down their mortgage early should consider using a second because they can focus extra payments on the second, reducing their blended interest rate as they pay that loan down quickly. By removing the higher-interest second mortgage, the homeowner is able to lower their blended interest rate and reduce the total interest paid on their debt.

Limitations and Considerations

While the blended interest rate provides a simplified view of the total cost of borrowing, it’s important to recognize that this rate does not reflect the actual interest rate being applied to each loan individually. It’s merely an average that helps consolidate multiple rates into a single figure. The blended rate is useful for understanding the overall cost of multiple loans, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that the borrower is paying a uniform rate on both loans.

Additionally, second mortgages typically come with higher interest rates because they are riskier for lenders. In the event of foreclosure, the second mortgage lender is paid after the first mortgage lender, making second mortgages more risky to finance. This increased risk translates into a higher interest rate for borrowers. As a result, second mortgages often have a greater impact on the blended rate.

Stacks of money
NO monthly payment!

A Second Mortgage Without Payments?

Older homeowners may now keep their low-interest first mortgage and access equity by taking out a reverse mortgage second. This relatively new product is available for homeowners over 55 years of age. Besides not having payments to worry about payments and not having to disturb their current mortgage, qualifying for this mortgage is substantially easier than qualifying for a conventional mortgage.

Conclusion

A blended interest rate is a useful concept for homeowners managing multiple loans, such as a first and second mortgage. By calculating a weighted average of the interest rates on both loans, borrowers can simplify their financial planning, understand the total interest cost, and evaluate refinancing options. Understanding how to calculate and use a blended interest rate is an essential tool for homeowners seeking to manage their debt efficiently and make informed financial decisions.

What about your personal situation? If you are looking to tap into your home’s equity, call me and let me run the numbers for you. (Yes, of course I have a spreadsheet for that.)

—————————

Casey Fleming, Author

The Loan Guide (2014) and Buying and Financing Your New Home, (2023 – Available as an e-book or paperback wherever books are sold )

Mortgage Advisor, Silicon Valley Mortgage

408-348-3442 mobile

My Blog: www.loanguide.com

Facebook: Casey Fleming – Mortgage Advisor, Author, Speaker

Facebook: The Loan Guide Book

Loanguide@outlook.com

NMLS 344375 / DRE 00889527

 

Resources used in this article:

Investopedia: “Blended Rate: Definition, Examples, and Calculation Formula“

Leave your thought