Home Equity Lines of Credit (HELOCS)

Casey Fleming

Home Equity Lines of Credit are and excellent way to access the equity in your home with very flexible terms, giving you control over how much it will cost you over time.

In almost all cases an equity line is written as a second loan on a property, meaning that there is a first mortgage in place, and an equity line is placed behind it. An equity line is a second lien in these instances. An equity line is similar to a mortgage in that your property is used as collateral for the loan.

However, an equity line differs dramatically from what you think of as a mortgage. An equity line is a revolving line of credit. You can draw on the line when you need cash, pay it back as you can, and draw more cash out again.

Because I work with a number of financial planners as referral partners, I’ve written a lot of equity lines. Used wisely, an equity line can be a valuable tool for financial management.

While equity lines are not for everyone, they can be a great product, and I highly recommend them for a lot of clients. The terms you need to know about on an equity line are as follows:

Draw Period

An equity line is never open-ended. There is a period during which you may draw money whenever you need, but at the end of the draw period you cannot draw any more cash. The most typical draw period is ten years. This means that you only have the right to draw on the line for ten years.

During the draw period the minimum payment is typically equal to the accrued interest on the loan. (In other words, payments are interest-only.) If you make only your minimum payment, you will pay no principal down during this period.

Payback Period

Once the draw period is over you enter the payback period. Over this period, you must pay back all of the money owed on the loan plus interest. You therefore must begin making amortized payments. This period starts when the draw period ends and is typically set at fifteen or twenty years. During this period your interest rate is still adjustable so your minimum payment may change. You will still receive monthly statements during this period telling you what your fully amortized payment is each month.

Adjustable Rate

All equity lines have adjustable interest rates. The four most important factors are the index, the margin, the adjustment period, and the adjustment caps.

Index

Most equity lines use Prime Rate as an index. The Prime Rate is the interest rate that major banks charge their most creditworthy large corporate borrowers. This index is a little different than those used for conventional adjustable-rate mortgages, because although it is market-driven in a sense, it tends to track a rate set by the Federal Reserve called the discount rate. This is the rate that the Federal Reserve charges banks to lend them money for a very short term, and thus closely (in theory) represents the cost of short-term funds to the banks.

Consequently, unlike other market-driven indices, the Prime Rate does not adjust daily and does not fluctuate much in the short term. In the long term, however, it can fluctuate dramatically. In the early 1980s the Prime Rate was as high as 21.5%!

The Prime Rate has fluctuated between less than 1% to over 18% since 1980.
The Prime Rate hasn’t been sky high for 40 years; but it could happen again.

Here is a history of the Prime Rate over the last 18 years:

Margin

The margin will be set by your agreement with the bank, just like in an adjustable-rate mortgage. During the Mortgage Boom of the early 2000s it was not uncommon for a highly creditworthy borrower to have a permanent margin as low as -0.25% or on rare occasion even better. This meant that the interest rate on your equity line would be set at 0.25% lower than the current index value. At the time, the Prime Rate was typically in the 7% to 9% range, so your rate would have been 6.75% to 8.75% at any given time.

During the Great Recession, however, the Federal Reserve reduced short-term rates that they use as benchmarks to lend to banks (or for banks to lend to each other) to nearly zero in order to lower the cost of borrowing and boost the economy. The Prime Rate, which is set by major banks, tends to run in line with short-term rates. Therefore, the Prime Rate during this period has been running at 3.25%. A borrower with a margin of -0.25%, as an example, was paying only 3.000% on their equity line during this time.

That’s a great deal for the borrower, and not such a good deal for the lender.

Lenders do learn, and today I don’t see any lenders offering an equity line with a permanent margin that low. In addition, most banks have established a floor interest rate—a rate which your interest rate cannot go below, even if the Prime Rate drops to zero.

Few borrowers understand how important the margin is to their long-term cost of borrowing, but it is critical to the profitability of the equity line to the lender. Consequently, margins vary considerably today. It is the easiest way for the lender to increase the profitability of the loan without borrowers understanding how it impacts their cost. So aggressive shopping can save you thousands of dollars over the life of the equity line. Pay attention to the permanent margin you are offered.

Adjustment Period

Most equity lines are written so that the interest rate can adjust daily. Since they are based on the Prime Rate which doesn’t adjust daily, however, in practice your interest rate will adjust infrequently. When the Prime Rate adjusts, your interest rate will adjust the same day. The adjustment period is defined in your Equity Line Agreement, and when your interest rate adjusts your lender will tell you in your monthly statement.

Adjustment Caps

There are typically no periodic adjustment caps with equity lines. However, the Prime Rate is usually adjusted by no more than a quarter point at a time, so in practice your interest rate is not likely to adjust more than 0.250% on any day. (Historically, however, it has adjusted by as much as 0.750% in one day.)

Most equity lines do have a lifetime cap, however, and most are set at 18%. It has been nearly 40 years since the Prime Rate was so high that a typical equity line would yield that high a rate, but it could happen.

Common Terms to Watch For

Teaser rates

When is the quoted rate not actually your rate? Well, that happens a lot. This is known as a teaser rate. The initial margin (and thus interest rate) quoted is good for a certain period of time, usually for three to six months. After that the interest rate will rise. Lenders structure a loan offer this way because folks tend to just pay attention to the initial number (the one in a larger, bold font and all caps) and ignore the fine print.

If your loan has a teaser rate your Equity Line Agreement will typically define it as an “Introductory” rate: for example, Prime plus zero. In this case your introductory rate will equal the Prime Rate for the introductory period. After that your permanent rate will have a margin greater than your introductory rate. 1.000% or higher is pretty common.

In a few cases I used this to my client’s advantage. Kim and Dave came to me and wanted to fund an addition on their home. Interest rates were somewhat high and they had a pretty good existing first mortgage, so refinancing their existing first was not an attractive option. As we discussed above an equity line can be an effective way to finance remodeling or an addition, for two very good reasons:

  1. You don’t need to draw the money out until you need it to pay for something, and
  2. You do not pay interest or even make payments until you have drawn the money.

But they had a choice. They could take a permanent rate of Prime + zero, or an introductory rate of Prime – 1.000 for six months, and then the rate would go to Prime + 0.500. We discussed how long it would take to complete the project, and they thought it would take six to nine months.

We waited until they were ready to begin construction and then closed on an equity line with an attractive introductory rate. It indeed took about nine months for them to finish the project. In the first six months they paid 1% less in interest than if they had taken the line without the introductory rate. They paid 0.500% more for three months, and then when they finished the project, we refinanced them into a new first loan wrapping both the existing first and equity line into a 30-year fixed.

So, watch out for teaser rates, but be aware that you can use them to reduce your borrowing costs in certain cases.

Interest Rate Floor

After 2008 many lenders instituted an interest rate floor on their equity lines. This works just like an interest rate cap, except that the interest rate can never go below a certain rate. The most common I have seen is a floor of 4% to 5%. If your equity-line agreement contains this provision, regardless of how low the Prime Rate goes your interest rate will not go below this level.

Maximum Rate—Lifetime Cap

Most equity lines have a lifetime cap of 18%. There is a problem with this, in my opinion, having to do with whether you can afford the equity line or not

Most lenders will qualify you (determine if you can afford the payments) using the assumption that you have drawn the maximum on your equity line and that the interest rate has risen to 12%.

In other words, if you have a $100,000 credit limit on your equity line the lender (for the purpose of underwriting the loan) assumes that you have drawn out the entire amount and that your interest rate has risen all the way to 12%, far above the (as an example) 6% where it sits today. Your actual minimum payment at today’s rate, assuming you draw the entire amount, would be $100,000 x 6% / 12 months = $500. For qualifying purposes, however, the lender would estimate your payment at $1,000. ($100,000 x 12% per year / 12 months)

This sounds relatively safe, doesn’t it? They assume that your payment will be more than three times what it actually will be when you close.

However, most lenders also allow a fairly high debt ratio on their equity-line product. This means that they might allow you to commit 43% of your gross income to your debt service. (Your minimum monthly housing payment and all other debt obligations total 45% of your gross income.If interest rates rise dramatically so will your payment.

So what happens if interest rates get out of control and the rate on your equity line goes to 18%? Let’s take a look:

In our example your initial interest rate is 6%, and your payment is only $500.

But what if rates spiral out of control? Your rate could go to 18%. If so, you’re payment now jumps to $1,500, a huge increase. Your lender thought you could afford a $1,000 payment when they qualified you, but it’s much higher than that now.

Can you afford this? Maybe, maybe not.

This is a worst-case scenario. It is not likely to happen. But it could.

Ask your loan officer what the worst-case scenario is and consider carefully if you think can deal with this. If you feel that the highest payments possible would “put you over the top,” lower your sights and buy a less expensive home, or consider using a fixed-rate second mortgage.

The important point to remember is this: pretty much all lenders will have the same lifetime cap, so you probably can’t shop and get a better one. The only thing you can do about this is not to borrow more than you can afford to pay in the worst-case scenario; keep the line amount within your affordable range.

Annual Fees

There is considerable difference between the annual fees that lenders charge. Some lenders offer equity lines with no annual fee at all, while others charge hundreds of dollars per year to keep the line open. However, the annual fee alone does not tell the whole story.

Suppose you are comparing two equity lines, one is at Prime plus 1 and has a $50 annual fee. The other is offered at Prime plus 1.25, with no annual fee. Which is a better deal? Say you think you will carry a balance of $20,000 most of the time. The no-fee equity line will cost you an additional $50 per year in interest. ($20,000 x 0.25%.) In this case, the lines are about a wash: a $50 annual fee vs. $50 more in interest per year. Would you reject the line with the annual fee? I know many clients who would.

What if your credit limit on the line was $50,000 and you had to draw out the total amount due to an emergency? (e.g. a really cool sailboat comes on the market and you just have to have it.) Your additional interest cost on the line is now $125. ($50,000 x 0.25%.) If you selected the no-fee equity line at the higher interest rate, you are now spending $125 per year to save $50.

Ask whether your equity line has an annual fee, but don’t automatically reject the line because it does. Compare the annual fee of the equity line—a fixed and known cost—with the additional interest cost based on the principal balance that you think you will typically owe.

Up-Front Costs

In the past you could generally get an equity line either directly from the bank or from a mortgage broker with no up-front costs or fees. After 2008 most banks stopped offering this product through the broker channel, so mortgage brokers now have fewer banks to work with, and usually have to charge some fees to get the HELOC for you.

Today very few lenders offer true no-fee lines. The up-front fees should be quite limited, though. You might be asked to pay for an appraisal fee in advance, and you might be asked to pay for some title fees or for a processing or administration fee.

A quick search on the internet will reveal that some banks or credit unions are still offering equity lines with no up-front fees, but their annual fees, early closure fees, and margin might mitigate the benefit of that.

As you shop for an equity line, be aware of the up-front fees. Don’t automatically reject a bank that charges them; the ongoing fees might make an equity line much more expensive than one from a local bank that charges some reasonable fees up front.

Pre-Payment Penalties / Early Closure Fees

Today lenders do not have pre-payment penalties on loans secured by your personal residence. Many, however, have early closure fees. The difference between a pre-payment penalty and an early closure fee is, well, nothing really. They might work a little differently in practice, but the effect is the same; you must pay money if you pay off your equity line before a certain date, regardless of whether it is called a penalty or a fee.

Most of the equity lines I’ve seen have an early closure fee the first three years, and after that it is waived. The fee can also be quite low compared to many pre-payment penalties, and might be only a couple of hundred dollars.

In practice most folks would rarely close out their line before the early closure fee expires, so while it is good to be aware of it, an early closure fee should rarely be the deal-breaker in choosing between equity lines.

Strategy – What to Consider

Purpose

What are you using the line for? How you intend to use the equity line will often direct you to favor certain terms over others. The purpose of the line will often drive how long you will likely take to pay it off.

Initial draw

How much cash do you need immediately? Some lines require that you draw a large amount initially in order to get the loan with no up-front fees. That’s fine if you need it, but not if you don’t. Do you need to draw the money out immediately? If not, avoid an equity line where it is required, or you must pay interest to borrow money you don’t need, negating one of the best features of the equity line over a fixed loan.

Time Frame

How long will you need the money? An equity line is probably not, in my opinion, the best way to borrow money for a long period of time. They all carry adjustable interest rates, and the longer you hold the equity line the longer you expose yourself to the risk of rising rates.

If you need the money you are borrowing for an extended period of time, consider using a fixed-rate equity loan rather than an equity line, or refinancing your first mortgage altogether.

Long-Term Plans

Do you intend to close the line when you are done using it? Some folks use an equity line for short-term needs, such as a remodel, and either pay the line off or consolidate their first mortgage and equity line into a new first mortgage when they are done with it.

If you only need to have cash from the equity line available for a short period of time, low up-front fees and a low or no early closure fees are more important than the margin or the annual fees.

Ongoing Use

(Business owners should get a low permanent margin.)

Small business owners often use an equity line as a business line of credit. Your accountant might not want you to commingle personal assets with business, but you will almost certainly save a great deal of money compared to a typical business line of credit.

Some clients now use large lines of credit to buy distressed properties, paying off the line after they have spruced them up and sold them. These clients need large amounts of cash for short periods of time. Using an equity line allows them to move fast on a great deal, avoid fees and costs on a new mortgage, and have the money available again when the project is done.

If you are going to use your line of credit periodically for ongoing cash flow needs the permanent margin and the annual fee could be the most important consideration.

Conclusion

The greatest benefit of an equity line is the flexibility it gives you to access the equity in your home easily and cheaply. The most obvious risk is that your interest rate can rise. The greater risk is that most homeowners use the line to pay for short-term assets or even current living expenses, and don’t make a plan to pay it off before the draw period ends, so they are forced to either roll into a new line, or convert the unpaid balance into long-term debt. An equity line is a poor choice for that.

Over time, properly planning and using an equity line can save you thousands of dollars over the life of the line.

Casey Fleming, Mortgage Advisor and Author of The Loan Guide (2014) and Buying and Financing Your New Home (2023) and Insider’s Guide to Reverse Mortgages (2025)

NMLS 344375 / DRE 00889527

Enjoyed this article? Then check out my latest book on Amazon here or my YouTube channel here!

About Casey Fleming: Casey Fleming is a veteran mortgage advisor (NMLS 344375, CA DRE 00889527) and Author of The Loan Guide and Buying and Financing Your New Home writes extensively about real estate finance, the real estate market, and the relationship between economics and finance. He advises clients throughout California, and is based in the heart of Silicon Valley.  He writes articles regularly for several online publications, is a subject-matter expert for two prominent finance-related sites, and is regularly quoted in articles for many other publications.

This article represents the opinions of Casey Fleming, and not necessarily those of any company or organization cited or mentioned in this web site.  This analysis was prepared with the best information available at the time it was written.  We do not have any magical insider information about bond markets, real estate markets or mortgage markets that would make economic projections any more reliable than any other source.  No warranty is made that the outcome will reflect the projections in this article, and neither the author nor LoanGuide.com are responsible for decisions that you make regarding your choices about your real estate or mortgage or those of your clients.

Fair use and redistribution

This article is copyrighted and may not be used or reprinted without permission.  However, we encourage you and freely grant you permission to quote short passages directly from the article, provided that when doing so, you attribute the author by linking to LoanGuide.com or this page, so that your readers can learn more about this topic.  Your link must be a “dofollow” link.

For any other use, please contact us at LoanGuide@Outlook.com

Resources used for this article:

Unites States Prime Rate – FedPrimeRate.com

Leave your thought